Rendering recovers proteins, fats and minerals from animal tissues that would otherwise require another form of treatment or disposal. Their use in feed, pet food, fertilisers and energy production can conserve resources by replacing other products, although the environmental benefit depends on the material recovered, its processing and the use that it replaces (Wilkinson et al., 2021; Woodgate, 2023; Lee et al., 2025). Feed-grade processed animal proteins (PAP) should be distinguished from higher-risk meat and bone meal directed to fertiliser or energy uses, since these streams differ in their raw materials and permitted applications (Woodgate, 2023).
Energy use and greenhouse gas emissions
Rendering requires heat to cook and dry the raw material, as well as electricity for processing equipment. In the United Kingdom, a life-cycle assessment of mammalian rendering showed that greenhouse gas estimates depended strongly on the use of natural gas or rendered fat as process fuel. The base-case estimate for PAP was 0.15 kg CO2-equivalent per kg of product for fossil emissions. Raw animal by-products were treated as wastes carrying no upstream livestock-production burden, and the system included the use of rendered fat as fuel; the estimate therefore describes that particular modelling approach (Ramirez et al., 2012).
Studies that assign some livestock-production impacts to the raw materials can give different results. An assessment of two poultry-rendering units in Portugal reported 726 kg CO2-equivalent per tonne of poultry by-product meal delivered to the feed producer, using economic allocation, which divides impacts according to product value. Process heat was a major contributor to climate impact, and assigning impacts by mass instead of value increased the estimates. These results concern poultry by-product meal and should not be transferred directly to mammalian meat and bone meal (Campos et al., 2020).
Consequently, comparisons between ingredients need consistent boundaries and allocation rules: whether livestock production is included, how impacts are divided between meat and by-products, the fuel used, and the products assumed to be displaced can all affect the conclusion (Ramirez et al., 2012; Campos et al., 2020; Al-Zohairi et al., 2023).
Industry assessments of carbon and water footprints
EFPRA's Sustainability Charter promotes recovery of animal by-products as part of a circular bioeconomy (EFPRA, 2021). Its subsequent white paper and case study present an industry-commissioned assessment by Mérieux NutriSciences | Blonk, using data from 48 European rendering production lines in 2020–2022. The published results use economic allocation and include farming, slaughter, transport to rendering and rendering, ending at the rendering-factory gate (EFPRA, 2024a; EFPRA, 2024b). Under these assumptions, EFPRA reports lower carbon footprints for rendered meals than for the soybean-meal market mix selected for comparison. Much of the upstream livestock burden is assigned to meat, while land-use-change emissions contribute to the soybean result. The white paper states that the plant-based comparators rely mainly on secondary database information and should be regarded as benchmarks rather than definitive comparisons (EFPRA, 2024a; EFPRA, 2024b).
The EFPRA assessment reports water use of approximately 6.6–15.3 litres per kg of PAP or meal from cradle to rendering-factory gate. In its comparisons, rapeseed meal used less water than rendered meals, while soybean meal used more; conclusions also depended on whether the comparison was expressed per kg of ingredient or per kg of protein (EFPRA, 2024b).
Recovery of feed resources and choice of use
Returning suitable animal proteins and minerals to feed can reduce demand for other protein and mineral sources (Lee et al., 2025). However, the preferred recovery route depends on the comparison made. A study using data from four European pig slaughterhouses found that increasing the proportion used as human food reduced impacts per kg of pork sold. Among the modelled uses of remaining by-products, pet feed performed better than biofuel and biogas (Al-Zohairi et al., 2023).
For aquafeed production in Italy, a life-cycle assessment estimated a 66.0 % reduction in climate impact per kg of a gilthead seabream feed formulated with poultry by-product meal relative to a fishmeal-based reference feed. The formulations also differed in other ingredients and their supply chains. This is therefore a result for the complete feed-production scenarios, ending at the feed-production gate, rather than an isolated effect of replacing fishmeal or a reduction demonstrated per kg of fish produced (Tignani et al., 2024).
Alternative treatment systems can also offer environmental benefits. A US study comparing slaughterhouse-waste rendering with anaerobic digestion found that digestion and co-digestion could perform better when credits for displaced energy and fertilisers were included. Methane leakage and the amount of mineral nitrogen fertiliser displaced were particularly influential (Wang et al., 2021).
Fertiliser use and nutrient losses
Meat and bone meal can recycle nitrogen and phosphorus to cropland, but its nutrient ratio may not match crop requirements. In Norway, a laboratory column experiment with bare soil showed that nitrogen mineralised from meat and bone meal could be lost through leaching before crop uptake; phosphorus losses were smaller, but increased with application rate. The findings support matching the rate and timing of application to crop demand rather than applying meal solely to meet nitrogen requirements (Jeng et al., 2009).
In a six-year field experiment in north-eastern Poland, an annual application of 1.0 tonne of meat and bone meal per ha, supplying 45.0 kg P/ha/year, met the phosphorus needs of a maize, wheat and oilseed rape rotation comparably to mineral phosphorus fertiliser at the same P rate. Higher annual inputs supplying 68.0 or 90.0 kg P/ha resulted in excessive phosphorus accumulation in the soil. Nitrogen and potassium supply were controlled across the fertilised treatments, so the comparison does not show that meal alone supplied all crop nutrients (Załuszniewska et al., 2022).
Soil conditions and processing also affect the environmental consequences of fertiliser use. In the Netherlands, a three-month laboratory incubation of sandy and loam soils found that nitrous oxide emissions from the animal-derived amendments tested, including meat and bone meal, did not exceed those from calcium ammonium nitrate. Emission patterns nevertheless varied with soil and amendment, so the result does not establish a general field-emission advantage for meat and bone meal (Cayuela et al., 2010). In Italy, a soil-incubation study found that alkaline thermobaric hydrolysis increased nitrogen availability from meat and bone meal without improving phosphorus availability or significantly changing carbon mineralisation (Ciurli et al., 2026).
Fertiliser recycling also involves trade-offs between impact categories. In a Swedish life-cycle assessment of Category 2 meat meal, recovering nutrients for crop production reduced greenhouse gas emissions and acidification relative to a system recovering energy and using chemical fertiliser, but increased total energy use and eutrophication impacts. The result depended strongly on the fuels displaced (Spångberg et al., 2011).
Combustion and local emissions
Combustion provides an outlet for meals that cannot be used in feed, recovering energy and leaving a phosphorus-rich ash (Woodgate, 2023). Its environmental performance depends on energy inputs and the heat, electricity or other products credited as replacements: an assessment of two Polish combustion technologies changed their relative ranking when avoided environmental burdens were included (Kowalski et al., 2021). Tests of a rotary combustion system showed that energy recovery could be combined with compliance with the air-emission limits examined (Bujak et al., 2020).
In China, laboratory experiments showed that meat and bone meal incineration ash could remove phosphate from synthetic wastewater and subsequently serve as a phosphorus-recovery material (Leng et al., 2019).
Rendering can also cause local odour nuisance. At a plant in southern Brazil, the biofilter tested did not achieve the odour-removal benchmark used by the researchers, indicating a need for improved biofiltration or additional treatment (Vieira et al., 2016).